Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Icing – Culinary Seasons
I can’t take credit for this carrot cake recipe, it is from Chef Bo Friberg’s, The Professional Pastry Chef. I like this recipe because it is easy to make, bakes up very moist and when you add the cream cheese icing, your guests will be amazed at how good this homemade carrot cake is. I have used different carrot cake recipes over my career and there is only one other that I feel meets this quality.
Jump to Recipe
Carrot Cake has its Roots in Pudding?
Yes, you read that right, carrot cake is believed to have started as a pudding back in 16th century Europe. Back then sugar and other sweeteners were expensive or hard to get and recipes called for carrots to substitute the sweetness. Often times the pudding recipes would call for bread crumbs to be added as a substitute for flour as well.
In 1824, a French chef for King Louis XVI made a recipe for Gateau de Carrotts translated is literally Carrot Cake. This recipe was published in England in a French cookbook in the late 1800s. Taking a look around heritage cookbooks from other European countries you will probably find some type of bread or cake baked with carrots. Italy has a version called Torta di Carote which uses almond flour or meal as well as flour but bakes up much more denser and is generally decorated with powdered sugar and not much else. Switzerland has a version that has hazelnuts and almonds with a Kirsch Brandy glaze.
During World War II, with the food rations in England, the Ministry of Food published a recipe for a cake using carrots as the sweetener as sugar was difficult to find.
Where and when the cream cheese icing comes into play is more difficult to track down. Sometime during and after the war the UK and the US beginning to bake carrot cake regularly, at some point along the way the addition of cream cheese icing was added.
Bread Flour? I thought we were making a cake?
The reasoning for bread flour in carrot cake goes into the science realm of food and baking. Without getting too technical, the bread flour has more gluten than cake flour which allows for a firmer structure to form in the cake. Remember, this recipe has 2 lbs of carrots in the recipe. Even in recipes that call for only a pound of carrots you will find the need for bread flour to give those carrots a lift. Think of carrot cake versus other types of cake, other types of cake are many times lighter and have a different crumb than that of a denser carrot cake.
If you wish, you can add additional spices such as nutmeg or clove to this recipe. Cinnamon is the only spice called for in this recipe but spice it up if you wish, start with a 1/2 tsp of nutmeg and a 1/4 tsp of clove. If you want to get really wild, substitute one of the tablespoons of cinnamon with 1 Tbl of cardamom for a different twist on the flavor.
Enjoy!
The cake can have chopped toasted walnuts or raisins added to the batter. Add them at the same time the carrots are added.
The recipe for Cream Cheese Icing is written for the amount pictured or in the video. I recommend doing a 1 1/2 times or 2 times the Cream Cheese Icing recipe to have more for decorating or if you want a thicker layer between layers or on top.